Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Talkbacks

First for once?
by strosmer
Jul 15th, 2008
08:39:16 AM
Can't wait...
by apolo_sputnik
Jul 15th, 2008
08:40:43 AM
To see this film!
Damn You Michael Bay
by MCMLXXVI
Jul 15th, 2008
08:40:53 AM
Damn You Michael Bay
Oh, gee, this is the greatest day of my life
by strosmer
Jul 15th, 2008
08:41:13 AM
I am finally a first poster. I can't believe it. I will take the rest of the day off in celebration. Anyway, didn't read the review, Massa, but I've no doubts that this will be the movie of the summer. In fact, I think it may be the only one that is actually any good.
hahah
by JBouganim1
Jul 15th, 2008
08:42:33 AM
i would have been first but i just sat here with a big ass fuckin smile on my face because i cant wait to see this movie
yadda yadda yadda
by Sailor Rip
Jul 15th, 2008
08:44:49 AM
The PowerPack movie will kick this films' ass
by classyfredblassy
Jul 15th, 2008
08:44:52 AM
If Jason Biggs gets the starring role and it is directed by the visionary Tim Story.
Nolan IS God...
by Nolan Is God
Jul 15th, 2008
08:48:13 AM
To say otherwise is blasphemy. BLASPHEMY!
CHEWBACCA IS BRUCE WAYNESES BABY DADDY!
by g-ride9000
Jul 15th, 2008
08:52:37 AM
ohh sorry "spoiler"
’’’’’’’’’’’’’’’wh at is this?
by g-ride9000
Jul 15th, 2008
08:53:16 AM
Alright...
by MrDuke118
Jul 15th, 2008
08:53:29 AM
Seriously I just need to see the fucking thing now. I have never looked forward to any film like this. And probably never will again
$200 million opening weekend?
by strosmer
Jul 15th, 2008
08:53:51 AM
Any takers? I think it's possible. And if it does do that, will it beat Titanic for all-time box office? I think this will draw multiple viewings from a broad range of moviegoers.
one zillion opening weekend,
by g-ride9000
Jul 15th, 2008
08:55:12 AM
i'd bet my mother's first born on it!
Bullshit aside...
by Nolan Is God
Jul 15th, 2008
08:57:07 AM
That was a great fucking review. I'm hoping against hope that this film lives up to the praise it's receiving. I'll know in 14 short hours.
AUGH!
by Geekhaterssuck
Jul 15th, 2008
08:58:30 AM
The weekend can't get here fast enough. I am so freaking ready to see this. I liked The Incredible Hulk, loved Iron Man, but this, if the hype is true I will want to make sweet love to this film over and over and over again.
This Movie Bave Me a Blowjob and a Million Dollars
by kevinwillis.net
Jul 15th, 2008
09:01:00 AM
Then cut my lawn. Best movie ever!

Seriously, can't wait to see it. Not letting the hype over-hype me.
Forget George Romero?
by GrandMuffTarkin
Jul 15th, 2008
09:01:35 AM
NEVER!
Each ticket comes with a free bowl of soup!
by g-ride9000
Jul 15th, 2008
09:04:24 AM
Tee-hee...
by Anti-fanboy
Jul 15th, 2008
09:05:44 AM
I mean, ahem, sounds great. Yeah... ...teehee!
I was looking forward to this anyway...........
by ChiefRoberts
Jul 15th, 2008
09:07:51 AM
but now I'm just dying for this to come out in the UK! You lucky Yanks getting this a week earlier than us, spare a thought for us limeys!
Forget Nicholson?
by NiceGuyEddie19
Jul 15th, 2008
09:11:18 AM
Sorry, but no matter how awesome Heath Ledger does, Jack Nicholson's performance will always be considered brilliant.
NiceGuyEddie19
by erichaislar
Jul 15th, 2008
09:14:08 AM
Wasn't he just playing himself? I'm not dissing you or trying to start a fight. Every time i see batman 89 i see jack not the joker. I don't understand why people think it was a good performance.
Boxoffice will be huge
by erichaislar
Jul 15th, 2008
09:16:47 AM
Spiderman 3 holds the record with $151,116,516. Thats a huge number if any movie can do it it's going to be this one. I will say $163,000 maybe a little more.
And no Katie Holmes..YAY!!!
by Knobules
Jul 15th, 2008
09:18:41 AM
Her smug and childish delivery was the only thing I didnt like about Begins. Glad she is back shes back at Toms house enjoying alien enemas where she belongs.
GrandMuffTarkin
by Freds_Balls_in_a_Mason_Jar
Jul 15th, 2008
09:19:31 AM
Fred think that Ceasar Romero
come on bros!
by SpawnofAchilles
Jul 15th, 2008
09:19:48 AM
Let's make this the highest grossing film of all time, fuck Titanic! It's man time!
Damn it ...
by GiveMeAnFinBreak
Jul 15th, 2008
09:21:12 AM
I try not to let my expectations get too high when walking into a flick like this. These reviews aren't helping with that.
erichaislar
by NiceGuyEddie19
Jul 15th, 2008
09:22:33 AM
He's an intense person, but I don't think he's that intense. I'll admit it's a much, much bigger stretch for Ledger, who I had never viewed as intense per se, but talented all the same.
I have this strange feeling Thrusday night will be the greatest
by The Guy Who Slept Through Everything.
Jul 15th, 2008
09:22:47 AM
Aside from losing my virginity and finding $100 bucks, I must try as hard as I ever have to not die before then.
When I see trailers in the theater
by dr sauch
Jul 15th, 2008
09:23:52 AM
I literally close my eyes, plug my ears, and sing to myself. I want to be so fucking fresh going into this. I'm gonna see it next wednesday at like 12:30 am, so that the theater will (hopefully) be devoid of 13 yr olds and parents with their 30 infant children.
TDK will do your taxes
by g-ride9000
Jul 15th, 2008
09:24:30 AM
I don't get
by snowtires
Jul 15th, 2008
09:25:09 AM
why people are all over Nicholson's nuts about his Joker in the first Tim Burton movie. It's just Jack playing Jack, like he does in 99% of every movie he's even been in, except maybe upping the campiness a little bit. Going back and looking at that movie, even compared to Batman Begins, the whole thing (Burton's Batman) seems like a huge joke, the movie doesn't even hold a candle to what Nolan has been able to do.
I think if this film is as good as it sounds, and by that..
by NomoredirtyjokespleaseweareYanks
Jul 15th, 2008
09:25:52 AM
...I mean to be mentioned as Gofather-like, I think it will beat ROTK in international box office.
Dammit, meant Godfather
by NomoredirtyjokespleaseweareYanks
Jul 15th, 2008
09:26:30 AM
Cunting Hell.
Going to break records...
by WickedJester
Jul 15th, 2008
09:27:21 AM
The amount of additional shows theaters are adding is a sign of the money this movie will bring in. It sounds like most of it may be made on repeat viewings, which is such a rarity these days.

It's been said a million times, but

'And here we ... go.'
Yes, but did you LIKE it?
by henrydalton
Jul 15th, 2008
09:28:44 AM
free i hate jack nicolson pin with every TDK ticket
by g-ride9000
Jul 15th, 2008
09:28:51 AM
I wish they'd be less profuse with the praise...
by GaiustheBrave
Jul 15th, 2008
09:29:16 AM
This has all the chances of kicking my ass midnight on Thursday, but I am afraid that we're being set up for disappointment with the all the Harry-isms. I don't remember ever going into a movie with such high expectations and coming out fully satisfied. I think Hellboy 2 wouldn't have been so painful to watch if I had gone in not expecting more. Instead, I got "Hellboy: Special Edition" by George Lucas. God save "The Hobbit"
Nicholson's Joker...
by WickedJester
Jul 15th, 2008
09:29:27 AM
Is essentially a younger version of Costello from the Departed, watch them back to back ... you'll see.
fanboys critical facilities put on hold...
by bennie garcia
Jul 15th, 2008
09:30:26 AM
just seen this film, and while it maybe the greatest batman story ever told that doesn't hid the fact that this movie takes some serious mis-steps...anybody expecting a masterpiece will be disappointed...lower your expectations people...
snowtired
by Geekhaterssuck
Jul 15th, 2008
09:31:10 AM
Got to agree with you 100%. I remember being 13 and loving Burton's Batman but seeing it after Batman Begins I'm just like "eh." It's Jack playing himself with makeup on and I just don't see Batman when I look at Michael Keaton. It was the weakest part of the movie for me when I saw it the first time and it still is. I don't hate it, it's just weak compared to BB. None of the previous films have aged well at all.
"Iron Man was an explosive series of action sequences"
by Mr. Profit
Jul 15th, 2008
09:34:18 AM
I liked this review a lot. But the main thing that stuck out wasn't even a thing about "The Dark Knight". It was about the above comment. What explosive series of action sequences? Because I only saw a few. And they didn't take my breath away. They were just typical action movie stuff.

I can't wait to see this though. I ordered my IMAX tickets 3 weeks ago. And I bypassed Manhattan. Because I know NYC is going to be crazy. I'm checking it in Westchester County.

bennie garcia
by WickedJester
Jul 15th, 2008
09:34:18 AM
Debbie Downer, party of one, you're table is ready.
you're = your. damnit!
by WickedJester
Jul 15th, 2008
09:34:43 AM
So Massawyrm, did you like it?
by ZoeFan
Jul 15th, 2008
09:34:56 AM
When films get praise like this film is getting, it scares me. The only complaints I've read on the net so far is complete pompous shit.
TDK will reinvent the industry...twice
by g-ride9000
Jul 15th, 2008
09:35:37 AM
Mr. Profit
by WickedJester
Jul 15th, 2008
09:35:48 AM
I'm heading to the Cradle of Aviation in Garden City, heard it's a great facility...
This movie...
by NiceGuyEddie19
Jul 15th, 2008
09:38:50 AM
Has a hell of a lot of hype to live up to from AICN alone. It's this sort of gushing that sets people up for some degree of disappointment.
it’s Massawyrm’s choice of font.
by ArcadianDS
Jul 15th, 2008
09:40:18 AM
way to draft your review in a font that isn't a global standard.
The Joker ...
by Animation
Jul 15th, 2008
09:40:39 AM
... should be equal parts hilarious and scary. Was he funny in this? If not, then its just another dark take on the Joker, of which there have been too many recently. I dont really want the Joker to be a brilliant nutjob killer in clown make-up. He has to also be funny. Unlike what others have said, the victim SHOULD get the joke, and if you think you aren't safe, some guilty part of you should want to laugh along. I'm hoping he wont just be a hard-a$$ nut with paint on his face. We'll see. I'm sure the movie will be brilliant either way tho, im just picky about the Joker.
Kent Brockman on Hyperbole
by Geekgasm
Jul 15th, 2008
09:40:54 AM
"Ladies and gentlemen, I've been to Vietnam, Afghanistan and Iraq, and I can say without hyperbole that this is a million times worse than all of them put together."
Jesus Christ..........
by Jabber_Jaw
Jul 15th, 2008
09:41:27 AM
The reviews for this movie are insane!! Godfather II and Empire Strikes Back comparisons! Way to completely pump up my expectations...
i'm filled with a strange dread too...
by smudgewhat
Jul 15th, 2008
09:43:00 AM
i think this movie is going to psychologically frightening much in the way of Clockwork Orange or a david lynch thriller. i expect it to stay with me. but i can't wait to see it! into the MAW
What I really need is a Vern review.
by greenstyle92
Jul 15th, 2008
09:43:02 AM
He's about the straightest shooter on this site regarding geek movies. And while I'm sure he'll eventually review it, it'll probably be only on his website, not AICN.
Animation...
by ZoeFan
Jul 15th, 2008
09:43:43 AM
Since the TV series in the 60s, when has the Joker been silly to anybody but himself?
But if you really need some room to air doubts...
by greenstyle92
Jul 15th, 2008
09:45:56 AM
Check out Rotten tomatoes. 3 negative reviews are taking the piss out of it's score. It stands at 88%. Which is not at all bad. But still.

It remains to be seen if this is an actual great movie or if fanboys flush from excitement just think it is. At the beginning of summer, everybody was creaming over Iron Man and Incredible Hulk. Now, not so much, particularly with Hulk.
Animation..?
by WickedJester
Jul 15th, 2008
09:47:33 AM
As a long time Joker fan, I've always found that the only person who finds his jokes funny are, well, himself. (I know that's been said a ton on this site too)

He's a lot like Dane Cook in that aspect, except he doesn't YELL ALL HIS LINES.
ZoeFan
by Animation
Jul 15th, 2008
09:50:01 AM
I havent really seen the 60s series. I'm basing this off simply reading the comics (mostly from the 80s onward) as well as the DCAU (tho they usually kept the body count down in the DCAU with the exception of the uncut Batman Beyond Joker movie). I have read exchanges in the comics between the Joker and other characters that had me in stitches and wanting to laugh at what he did next, even though he was killing people and screwing up people's whole lives and it was horrific. So, he has to be hilarious (not silly). Thats just my opinion. Otherwise he is just a crossdressing, or um clowndressing, serial killer. Nothing special there.
Too much hype makes me suspicious...
by Hooded Justice
Jul 15th, 2008
09:50:29 AM
There's NO WAY the movie can live up to this amount of hype. Massawyrm or Moriarty or whoever's seen the movie, can you answer these questions:

1. Gotham City. In Batman Begins it was very bland and boring - clearly a real, modern city, rather than the macabre, open air lunatic asylum of the Batman mythology. Nolan' Gotham could just as well have been the setting for a Jason Bourne movie, or a Mission Impossible movie, or a Muppets in Manhattan movie. Has Nolan solved this problem?

2. Car chases. These have been incredibly tedious in every movie since The French Connection cornered that particular cliché. The car chase in Batman Begins was boring in the extreme and I switched off for it. Please tell me there are no car chases in The Dark Knight.

3. Batman's costume. It's stupid. All that armour plating? How can he possibly move? He looks like a robot - worse than the nipple costume in Batman And Robin. This isn't a question - I see from the poster they haven't solved this one.

4. Action scenes. Are there any this time round? There were none in Batman Begins. Oh yes, there were a few blurry, shakey bits with choppy editing, but I switched off for those, as I'm sure most people did. Are there any proper action scenes this time?

The characters: In Batman Begins, they were extremely tedious. Has Nolan managed to inject any personality into the characters this time around?

The plot: Batman Begins had a rambling, boring plot with no sense of tension or high stakes. I found myself switching off for the dull exposition. Is the plot better this time around? If so, how?

WickedJester
by Mr. Profit
Jul 15th, 2008
09:51:57 AM
It boggles the mind how people who reside in NYC only think about Lincoln Center's IMAX. Like it's the only one around. I go to the City Center Cinema De Lux in White Plains. It's a nice facility, free of the crazy idiots. And they also have many screens that show "Director's Hall" screening where you choose your seats. When I saw Indy 4, I saw it on Digital Projection in Director's Hall and the ushers waited by the door and escorted you to your seat. Good shit for the same price. They do the same for IMAX too.

I have heard from my Long Island buds that Cradle of Aviation was a nice place (outside of IMAX). I got to check it one day.

Animation...
by ZoeFan
Jul 15th, 2008
09:53:16 AM
No one else was laughing. So you and the Joker have something special.
3 Negative RT Scores
by Mr. Profit
Jul 15th, 2008
09:55:18 AM
1 is from Star Magazine so that already takes from it's credibility because they are probably Heath Ledger STANS who are still pissed that they don't have him around to stalk. The other 2 made no sense. One said the movie was too dark. Which is dumb since the film is called "The Dark Knight". I'm sure if it's better than Begins, I'll like it. Because I enjoyed that film very much.
wickedjester
by bennie garcia
Jul 15th, 2008
09:55:29 AM
dude i don't take any pleasure from this, i'm just saying i had a nagging feeling of disappointment coming away from the flick...i think because they came so close to getting the classic status that massawyrm claims it has, but at times it just becomes damn convoluted...i bought into this kind of unreserved hype and it ended up lowering the experience for me...i mean its still a really good flick dont get me wrong, but i'd just say dont expect a flawless movie...
the first Oscar quality superhero movie was Ang Lee's Hulk
by DarthBakpao
Jul 15th, 2008
09:56:17 AM
Godfather, Empire Strikes Back quality?
by kwisatzhaderach
Jul 15th, 2008
09:56:28 AM
OK, this film must be amazing then. Trying not to get my hopes up too high though...
Damn
by m_reporter
Jul 15th, 2008
09:57:14 AM
And I thought Quint creamed TDK up in all possible superlatives. But no, superlatives galore is an understatement for this review.

Now I want to see it even more than before... never thought it would be possible.

what about the SHAKYCAM!?!?!?!?
by halibut
Jul 15th, 2008
09:58:05 AM
the first movie was one of the best stories but was RUINED every time there was a fight because of the damn shakycam. does this movie have the same lame shakycam fight scenes?!?!?!?
bennie
by WickedJester
Jul 15th, 2008
09:59:10 AM
Just busting balls, I don't expect perfection, I just expect to have a 'smile put on that face.'
Couldn't agree with Massa more.
by Sidius
Jul 15th, 2008
09:59:36 AM
The film is absolutely brilliant and the further I get away from having seen it the more powerful and resonant it gets. It's an absolute powerhouse.

I particularly agree with Massa on two things in particular:

1. My main concern after having left the film was in regards to the possibilities for a third film. There is absolutely NO way Nolan can do better work than he did here. It's not possible. This was the perfect storm of acting, direction and spectacle. There is no villain in the third film, no master stroke of casting that can match Ledger's performance here. There will be a drop off to film 3 - it's unavoidable.

2. I agree with Massa on Ledger's Oscar shot as well. It's his to lose. I can't believe there will be a better performance this year from anyone. I went into the film fully expecting to see a performance that was overhyped solely because of the genre it was in and the subsequent actor's demise - and I was blown away by a performance that is as good as anything I've seen in the last 10 years in any genre. Ledger's Joker will join Johnny Depp's Jack Sparrow (1st Pirates film) and Daniel Day Lewis' Daniel Plainview as one of the iconic performances of the last 10 years. Ledger's Joker in TDK is one of the top 5 villains in the modern era of film.

I know to most fans it seems like this film is being overhyped...it's not. Yes there will be those who think a comic book film should always be light and funny and campy to be effective and to them this film will be a dark twisted disaster. But this is a Batman film - and he is nothing if not sunny. Nolan gets it and nails it. Batman is the darkest of the comic creations and now he's also in the best of the comic book films.
Mr Profit
by WickedJester
Jul 15th, 2008
10:00:16 AM
Hmm Director's Hall.. I wont get that, but atleast I'll get to see it in it's IMAX glory opening night. Most of the shows are sold-out for the first few days... wonder how many they hold...
ZoeFan
by Animation
Jul 15th, 2008
10:00:50 AM
Heh. Hrm. Haha! HA HA HA HA! And stuff. :) Anyway, I am looking forward to the movie, no doubt. Also, I guess I've grown to accept that film universe versions of characters dont have to match the comic book ones, so I'm sure I'll like this Joker just fine. It has to be better than Nicholson. :)
Free steadycam lessons with every TDK ticket
by g-ride9000
Jul 15th, 2008
10:04:04 AM
WickedJester
by Mr. Profit
Jul 15th, 2008
10:04:06 AM
I know that in Manhattan even the added 6AM showing are done. This movie is an event I haven't seen in a very long time. I knew it would do well. But I never imagined that the anticipation for it would be so widespread. My friend is trying to score tickets but Lincoln Center is sold out until next week. Crazy.
Hooded Justice
by WickedJester
Jul 15th, 2008
10:06:53 AM
If you watch the trailers or even as far as the first 6 minutes, you'll see Nolans Gotham could very well be a city you'd drive through. Whether or not that's how you want it, is up to you.

I don't see you enjoying this movie because you seem to not enjoy anything about Begins or what Nolan was/is trying to accomplish by placing Batman in a 'real universe.'

Let's face it, if he was wearing grey spandex and a mask with eyebrows drawn on them, people would have a problem with that as well.

I can understand the cinematography complaints about the fight scenes, but you really didn't like the rumbler chase?
Please don't make a third...
by DoctorWho?
Jul 15th, 2008
10:08:43 AM
I haven't seen this yet but I don't want a trilogy. It almost always gets fucked up. Heath's gone and I can't imagine lightning striking twice. I hope I'm wrong. I haven't been this stoked for a movie since FOTR. I'm making my wife crazy!
Mr. Profit
by WickedJester
Jul 15th, 2008
10:09:08 AM
It's amazing. The Cradle of Aviation usually closes at 10:30 (I think) and is has showings as late as 1:15AM every night through Sunday. 11PM showings thereafter.

I'm not sure the body of Christ would have as many viewings :-P
wickedjester
by bennie garcia
Jul 15th, 2008
10:09:55 AM
don't worry, it certainly will do that...i'll see it again and enjoy it more second time round as i now know what to expect...
The third film...
by WickedJester
Jul 15th, 2008
10:11:29 AM
If Nolan doesn't come back, and they use Riddler -- you need someone that can make a good mystery. David Lynch? Imagine Se7en, but with Batman and the Riddler instead of 'John Doe'...

Just not sure who's head would be in the box....
This film will feed your pets when you go away for the weekend
by Falling_Gruber
Jul 15th, 2008
10:12:29 AM
And I meant Fincher, not sure why I put Lynch ..
by WickedJester
Jul 15th, 2008
10:14:28 AM
Guess I shouldn't be doing client's paperwork while on a TB.
Great, now every superhero movie will be dark and "real"...
by SpyGuy
Jul 15th, 2008
10:15:08 AM
Moon Knight, your time has come!
Nolan.......Would He? Could He?
by Da B-Meister
Jul 15th, 2008
10:15:37 AM
If Nolan continues after TDK with yet a third Batman flick......would he go ahead and give us another Batman vs Riddler & Two-Face flick, to give the final kick in the face, car-battery to the nutsack of the trashy likes of "Batman Forever"?
Am I a bad person
by Charlie Murphy
Jul 15th, 2008
10:17:24 AM
if i jerked off to this review?
TDK will brush your teeth for you
by g-ride9000
Jul 15th, 2008
10:17:32 AM
Da B-Meister...
by greenstyle92
Jul 15th, 2008
10:19:21 AM
All reports indicate Two Face unambiguously dies at the end of TDK, meaning a Two-Face and Riddler reteam is not in the cards.
Thanks for your answer, Wickedjester...
by Hooded Justice
Jul 15th, 2008
10:20:23 AM
And to answer your question: no, I hated that car chase. But car chases are such a cliché of TV and cinema that the last time I found a car chase interesting was when I was about seven years old. After that they just became boring. And since the invention of the car chase, there have been SO MANY car chases - hundreds of thousands - that I honestly don't see how it's possible to make any car chase entertaining anymore. Better to leave them out altogether and try to come up with some other kind of action scenes.

Well, the whole idea of a caped superhero is so outlandish in the first place, that trying to stick him in a real modern city, with glass skyscrapers etc, just doesn't work at all. And it doesn't matter that they try to make his costume 'realistic' by adding all these modern materials to it - all they're doing is drawing attention to the problem. No, the best way is to make the city itself a surreal backdrop - as it is in the comic books - and then these costumed characters fit right in. I like the look of the costume (and lighting) in that fan film 'Dead End'. The film itself is utter garbage - but the look of the costume is the best I've seen on film.

TDK will decorate your spare room
by Falling_Gruber
Jul 15th, 2008
10:20:30 AM
No, Charlie Murphy
by greenstyle92
Jul 15th, 2008
10:22:33 AM
I actually Jerk off to the talk backs. I've got a Nintendo Wii, which makes one handed web surfing real easy.

The real question is... can you jerk off at the theater while watching the film? Normally I'd say, "No, that's what DVD is for." but considering the midnight shows are going to be exclusively hardcore Batman fans, I think they'd understand. They may even join in. Just make sure you give a heads up when you're about to fire off. I usually get at least a few seconds warning myself...
How G-ride jerks off in a theater=
by g-ride9000
Jul 15th, 2008
10:23:47 AM
POPCORN SURPRISE BABY!
Hooded Justice...
by ZoeFan
Jul 15th, 2008
10:25:36 AM
I know I'm just setting myself up to be ridiculed, but the car chase on the bridge in Bad Boys 2 was refreshing.
TDK will finish your calculus homework for you
by g-ride9000
Jul 15th, 2008
10:25:55 AM
g-ride9000
by ZoeFan
Jul 15th, 2008
10:27:34 AM
Or bring your girlfriend and you can give her the buttery bird.
Ronin
by Lost Jarv
Jul 15th, 2008
10:30:04 AM
If you're talking car chases.
...
by daroru
Jul 15th, 2008
10:30:37 AM
Mother. Fuck.
Chilling
by Scarbro
Jul 15th, 2008
10:32:40 AM
The more I see of Heath the more chills I get. I can't wait to see this!
Blues Brothers = great car chase
by irrelevntelefant
Jul 15th, 2008
10:39:16 AM
who hasn't wanted to just drive through a mall, really?
Zoefan...
by Hooded Justice
Jul 15th, 2008
10:39:45 AM
I wouldn't ridicule you, Zoefan. If you get a kick out of car chases, then more power to you. I think that I was born without the 'car chase gene'. I don't understand why they are in every action movie. I don't understand why they are entertaining. I don't even find cars interesting. It's like I'm car-blind, the way some people are colour-blind.

I also find the vehicle that Batman uses in Batman Begins to be completely ridiculous. I find it looks a lot sillier than the Batmobile in the sixties' TV series.

D.Vader
by just pillow talk
Jul 15th, 2008
10:43:11 AM
Isn't Wanted a comic book? (though from all the reviews, I guess it's easy to forget)
So, this is like TOTAL FUCKING DESTRUCTION?!?
by Motoko Kusanagi
Jul 15th, 2008
10:45:02 AM
Great!
A movie that will skull fuck all others
by dirtsandwich
Jul 15th, 2008
10:45:23 AM
"Hold on to your butts!" Come Thursday night, everyone is going to have Nolan's cinematic cock, his movie meat, deeply in all our asses.
Burtons Batman
by Knobules
Jul 15th, 2008
10:46:18 AM
Kim Bassinger screaming nonstop. Right up there with Temple of Doom and Mrs Spielberg. Cripes I can go home every night and listen to that shit. Why would I bother paying for it?
Joel Schumacher should be thanked....
by Tacom
Jul 15th, 2008
10:47:31 AM
for fucking up the Bat-franchise with his gay-ass movies so WB were forced to start over again!
Thank you greenstyle92
by Mr. Profit
Jul 15th, 2008
10:49:58 AM
For the Two Face heads up. The review was pretty spoiler free from significant plot points and then you go and say something that happens in the film that I hadn't heard about so far.
TDK will give your wife a foot massage
by g-ride9000
Jul 15th, 2008
10:51:57 AM
and you'll be thankful!
dirtsandwich
by Mr. Profit
Jul 15th, 2008
10:54:02 AM
Your comment makes no sense to me. Getting butt raped doesn't seem like an enjoyable experience in my book. So why would Nolan do that to us if his film owns and kicks our asses on Thursday? If we all love the film, wouldn't the analogy really be something that provides ultimate pleasure? Like waking up to a naked Kim Kardashian every morning?
TDK will still respect you in the morning
by Falling_Gruber
Jul 15th, 2008
10:54:14 AM
hooded justice
by Mr Gorilla
Jul 15th, 2008
11:03:32 AM
is right about the whole action sequence thing. Remember that first T-Rex attack in Jurassic Park? Or Tom Cruise breaking into Langley in the first Mission: Impossible? Gripping action set pieces that nailed your balls to the cinema seats for a good ten minutes or so. How come we don't get sequences like those any more?
It's no Comet Man.
by rev_skarekroe
Jul 15th, 2008
11:07:53 AM
YOU know what I mean.
DarthBakpao
by Mr_X
Jul 15th, 2008
11:09:34 AM
ang lees hulk was a pile of shite
im concerned.
by Mr_X
Jul 15th, 2008
11:10:23 AM
everyone who has reviewed this movie like its the second coming. just in case i miss this, ive booked my imax tickets
Certainly a lot of gushing from AICN reviewers
by strosmer
Jul 15th, 2008
11:18:27 AM
which is nearly always the case, or at least has been for every summer movie this year thus far. When I take a step back, none of the movies have hit it out of the ball park for me, not even Iron Man as enjoyable as it was. TDK promises to deliver. I won't get myself so up as to think it'll be ESB quality, but I wouldn't mind being pleasantly surprised if it is. I think it'll be bigger and badder than BB, and that's just fine by me.
More money that Titanic? For real?
by hank henshaw
Jul 15th, 2008
11:20:47 AM
That's hilarious. TDK is not family friendly. Sure it will make lots of money, and according to websites like this it is the Second Coming, but unless fanboys do what some girls did with Titanic, and pay 10+ times to see it, there is no way it will come even close to Titanic numbers. It might be the highest grossing movie of the year, but that's it. Batman Begins made "only" 205 MM. This movie is hyped way out of proportion, I can only compare it to The Phantom Menace's hype. I plan to do with TDK, what I did with BB (and I certainly don't regret), wait for rental.
The Empire Strikes Back ... ???
by screamster101
Jul 15th, 2008
11:26:14 AM
Wow... That is a bold statement to make.
Hank Henshaw
by still_RuSTeD
Jul 15th, 2008
11:27:17 AM
Nolan went through the troubles of digitally recording the movie in IMAX format, that lets you record only 3 seconds for every take, just so your fat lazy ass can enjoy it. You're a turdburglar of the highest order.
TDK will talk to your mom on the phone for you
by g-ride9000
Jul 15th, 2008
11:27:20 AM
for 2 hours
It's Superman 2????
by RobotDevil007
Jul 15th, 2008
11:31:13 AM
What, does Batman hit the Joker with a giant cellophane Bat? Superman 2 was hacked up crud... very strange to see it you use it that context.
TDK will do your laundry
by g-ride9000
Jul 15th, 2008
11:42:44 AM
Fucking Hell
by PrincessLeias_Poohole
Jul 15th, 2008
11:43:08 AM
I need to see this fucking film i cant wait any fucking longer. Fuck it
Hooded Justice, what are you talking aobut?
by Coughlins Laws
Jul 15th, 2008
11:45:49 AM
There were too high stakes. Liam Neeson there was trying to destroy all of Gotham City, which looked like some kind of Mega City that dwarfs NYCity. So, you don't think that making millions of people crazy so that they destroy a whole city is NOT high stakes? OK. There have been lower stakes in lots of superhero movies than that.
Sorry Mr. Profit, but this IS talk back.
by greenstyle92
Jul 15th, 2008
11:47:33 AM
And where did I stumble across this little spoiler? why, a Dark Knight Talk back it seems! I'll be more careful, but going to the talk backs before seeing the movie is the very definition of "asking for it."
The thing about the second coming...
by greenstyle92
Jul 15th, 2008
11:49:08 AM
Is we keep waiting for it and waiting for it but it never quite gets here. And if/when it does, well, you don't get to talk back about it.
I may be indecent Massawyrm but...
by KnarftheIndecent
Jul 15th, 2008
11:49:17 AM
That was the best review I have ever read you do.
Now if you combined Superman 1 & 2...
by ccchhhrrriiisssm
Jul 15th, 2008
11:55:16 AM
You might have a pretty decent movie. The first movie was epic (even if it lagged at times). The second was, um, silly and low budget? If they would have spent a good amount of money, the film would have been epic. But with studio execs that hated (and fired) Richard Donner...it just couldn't escape a low budget and unnecessary comic relief.
Dammit, I want to jump forward in time...
by The Dum Guy
Jul 15th, 2008
11:59:09 AM
I want to watch this movie.
No mention of Bale because...
by greenstyle92
Jul 15th, 2008
12:00:41 PM
If you read between the lines of the positive reviews, (and read the normal lines of the negative ones,) Bale as Bruce/Batman is one the film's lesser elements. It sounds he just completely continues his performance from the last one, which next to Ledger and Eckhart, suddenly makes him look kind of bland. In the positive reviews you see them say how this is "Ledger's Movie" or "Eckhart's Movie" or "It's more about Batman as a symbol." I didn't understand the translation of all that until I read the New Yorker's review.
dogphart3000...Obamination?
by ccchhhrrriiisssm
Jul 15th, 2008
12:01:07 PM
That would suck. I think Obama is a dick.
I can't wait for this movie!
by ccchhhrrriiisssm
Jul 15th, 2008
12:07:33 PM
This is the one film (other than Indy 4) that I have waited for.

Indy 4 was good (but not great). I don't know if this one (The Dark Knight) can live up to my expectations! My expectations are pretty high right now!

BTW, I can't wait for G.I.JOHN McCain, er, G.I. JOE too! There is something about heroes that I find fascinating! They are so much better than rhetorical fluff with little substance!
Christ, lets not drag politics into this one.
by greenstyle92
Jul 15th, 2008
12:11:22 PM
But between the two candidates, I'm fairly ambivalent. Very much considering not voting this time.
Hank Henshaw
by WickedJester
Jul 15th, 2008
12:13:01 PM
Titanic isn't exactly 'family friendly' either. Unless you like showing your little ones some t & a (not that there's anything wrong with that, I wish I had parents like you.)

Regarding the multiple viewings remark, if reviewers are lining back up to see it, why wouldn't Fanboy X? You aren't implying teenage girls are more obsessive than Fanboys are you?

Why people like you even come to a site like this is beyond me (afterall this is essentially one big comic book store put online), let alone feel the need to be the Negative Nancy of the talkback.

I'm not sure what's worse, glass-is-half-empty posters like yourself or g-rides incessant TDK will do this (insert stupid joke)posts..
PLEASE LET ME KNOW!!!!!!
by halibut
Jul 15th, 2008
12:14:12 PM
All I care about, are the fights done with Shaky cam?
i want to really see some scathing reviews for this
by blindambition238
Jul 15th, 2008
12:17:30 PM
cause as it is, I am already frothing at the mouth for this movie (have been since Begins), but its getting to the point where if this isnt the greatest movie of all time, I'm going to walk out "meh", and not able to enjoy anything else for the rest of my life.
Coughlins law: High stakes?
by Hooded Justice
Jul 15th, 2008
12:20:38 PM
No, there were no high stakes in Batman Begins. So they're going to take over the city? Kill the population? Take over the world?

Yawn. Go ahead, who cares.

You know who else threatens to take over/ kill/ enslave / poison a whole population?

Dr Evil. And Dr No. And Lex Luthor. And General Zod. And Goldfinger. And Syndrome. And EVERY single supervillain, superterrorist and superalien from the dawn of time. Which is why it's now used as a JOKE in spoof movies, like Austin Powers, Superhero Movie, Hot Shots part Deux, Naked Gun etc etc etc etc. Because:

Rule number 1 of serious action movies: NEVER try to make the audience feel empathy for some fictional anonymous population. Because we the audience won't give a shit. We don't know them. They're not real anyway. So go ahead and blow them away.

But get us to empathise with one or two INTERESTING, well-written, well-acted characters who face challenging personal dilemmas. THEN we'll care. THEN we'll understand the stakes.

Which is why movies like Aliens and Mission Impossible 3 work so well: I don't like Tom Cruise at all - but the stakes he's facing will potentially fuck him up personally. As for Sigourney Weaver, she's not saving the earth, she's saving a single little girl - and we see every goddamn emotion on her face as she plucks up the balls to face the monsters. Now THAT'S an action movie. So you can keep your 'Oh no! A bunch of bored extras are going to pretend to die!' plot, thank you very much. Put it in the same place as cars smashing into each other and flying through the air. Yawn

blind ambition, just check out "Rotten Tomatoes"
by greenstyle92
Jul 15th, 2008
12:21:58 PM
I'd recommend the New Yorker's review for a different take that might check some expectations, (He's still very favorable to Ledger, though.)
Nobody has mentioned HEAT?
by Gilkuliehe
Jul 15th, 2008
12:27:44 PM
I'm amazed. In the IMDB trivia section is stated Nolan was inspired by HEAT, and I must say I thought the exact same thing leaving the theater. There's a lot of Mann's tone in it, that soft blue quietness right in the middle of chaos. That shot of the Joker with his head outside the car (it's on the treilers) and the music, man what a fucking beautiful movie this is.

Wanna hear something fucked up? Last night I had awful fucking nightmares, and yes, I blame THE DARK KNIGHT. Amazing film. Truly amazing.

TDK will find your G-spot
by g-ride9000
Jul 15th, 2008
12:29:55 PM
Yay, there are finally negative reviews for this...
by The Dum Guy
Jul 15th, 2008
12:30:07 PM

I prefer to read negative reviews, since they can temper off my expectations. Although sometimes it kinda backfires, like watching Wanted or Hancock, not horrible but forgetable.
Apostrophes?
by Leto III
Jul 15th, 2008
12:31:05 PM
Massawyrm, love ya, man, I always read your reviews the second they go up....but ya gotta start using the almighty apostrophe.
I really hate it when...
by ccchhhrrriiisssm
Jul 15th, 2008
12:39:10 PM
...a film is reviewed as "the second coming" and then turns out to be b-o-r-i-n-g as a trip to a box company.

There have been far too many "good" reviews in the last two years that made me feel violated when I watched the film for myself.

That being said, IRON MAN was pretty good. I have very high hopes for THE DARK KNIGHT! With so many positive reviews, I am hoping for the best!
Massa, puh-leaze.
by Jaws Wayne
Jul 15th, 2008
12:47:17 PM
Looking forward to this film as much as the next bloke who posts here and do expect this movie to be worth checking out but comparing ANY movies to Star Wars V or the Godfather ones..., why would you compare these movies to this one, just say it's a motherfucker of a film we should all check out and we would get it. Great to read this is more than you could have hoped for, but I bet Empire and GF are very different beast compared to this Batman film. (Not that "Empire" and Godfather have anything in common by the way except that they're both very cool movies).
I think you pretty much summed up...
by Second Try
Jul 15th, 2008
12:48:45 PM
...why I was desliking the feel of the movie and didn't know the reason. I get it now. This is not a COMIC BOOK. This is a GRAPHIC NOVEL. I don't like GRAPHIC NOVELs... Too serious, too dark, too 90s... Bring me Cesar Romero, I want a funny Joker!
I may already hate this movie.
by Chewtoy
Jul 15th, 2008
12:50:05 PM
We'll see. I'll get around to seeing it next week, as I've got plans for this weekend. But seriously, the hyperbole rising off this thing is toxic. I have to keep reminding myself it's in the nature of early reviews to be crazy-over-the-top, as all anticipated movies reviewed that way seem to come back as either the greatest thing ever, or the most disrespectful, insulting piece of trash ever made. Either way, it has to be something that makes the writer that much more special for having experienced this life-changing event before the rest of us. I would say the odds of this movie not being massively over-rated as pretty slim right now.
Mama
by Second Try
Jul 15th, 2008
12:50:26 PM
TDK will be there on the hard days
by g-ride9000
Jul 15th, 2008
12:50:33 PM
Chewtoy
by Second Try
Jul 15th, 2008
12:51:09 PM
I think I may be getting there...
"HEAT was awful."
by I am the Terminator
Jul 15th, 2008
12:51:22 PM
Is your brain broken?
Let's put a smile on that face-Ah
by Second Try
Jul 15th, 2008
12:52:42 PM
Ledger
by Second Try
Jul 15th, 2008
12:54:58 PM
I think he got felt so bad with that depressing character and the other bad stuff in his life that he offed himself in an "accidental" overdose. How can I be afraid from an actor I pitty so much.
greenstyle92, Peter Travers mentioned Bale
by strosmer
Jul 15th, 2008
12:55:31 PM
in his review, saying, "Bale is electrifying as a fallibly human crusader at war with his own conscience." So there are some props for Bale out there, and I do look forward to seeing what more he brings to the role. Ledger is obviously going to get more attention in the early reviews. When it comes to The New Yorker, you can hardly expect a positive review of any summer blockbuster to appear in that snobby NY lib rag.
Gilkuliehe
by strosmer
Jul 15th, 2008
01:05:14 PM
Peter Travers (his is the only review I've read, so that's why I'm quoting him again) says of one of the action sequences, Nolan handles it "with a finesse for choreographing action that rivals Michael Mann's Heat."
HEAT was a poor movie
by Hooded Justice
Jul 15th, 2008
01:07:20 PM
It was terrible. Half of it was just a tedious shoot-out. The other half was the story of the lives of some seiously boring minor characters. I mean, WTF? Instead of telling us a story, they start to pad out the movie by concentrating on the henchmen! The extras!

And the scene where De Niro and Pacino - those two acting greats - finally get to meet has all the drama of a homemade cake contest. Utterly disappointing. The two great actors sit there grunting at each other in embarrassment. And why? Because there was NO SCRIPT for that scene. They had to make up their lines -and unfortunately NEITHER OF THEM ARE WRITERS. So all they could do was grunt and shrug their shoulders. It was terrible to watch. If the director had been serious he would have said, "Okay guys, we're going to stop and hire some writers to write dialogue for this scene." Completely unprofessional. That movie still gives me nightmares when I think of it. It's like an A-B-C of how NOT to do a crime drama.

The more I hear about The Dark Knight, the worse it sounds. I mean, comparing it to HEAT????? God, please no!

Come on guys! Doesn't ANYONE have ANYTHING positive to say about The Dark Knight?

Hooded Justice
by strosmer
Jul 15th, 2008
01:11:11 PM
What I'm getting is that ther is one scene that resembles a particular scene in Heat, and that would have to be the one scene in Heat that's undeniably worth watching. I don't think we need to worry about TDK being like Heat.
Sounds like this movie will do...
by chimp242
Jul 15th, 2008
01:12:22 PM
...until I can see Space Chimps.
An epic masterpiece, truly.
by Executor
Jul 15th, 2008
01:12:39 PM
What Nolan has done is not just make a comic book movie or a graphic novel, he has made a definitive movie on criminals and heroes, how they feed off each other and create each other (not literally, like Burton's Joker and Batman, but metaphorically...a great hero is going to attract super villainy to combat it, and vice versa).

One of the greatest things to be said about the film is that, like the Joker, the movie is unpredictable. Even though you know where Harvey ends up, you never really know where the movie is going. (Like, after the big Joker confrontation in the streets of Gotham...where the movie slowly heats up until in one of the most amazing scenes.)

What also makes this work is the pacing. This is Nolan's first truly linear film, but he takes his seamless editing style into a few tense sequences that cross-cuts between a few different groups effortlessly.

I don't get all the haters who come to this site because of their love of movies, and then when they finally get one that is legendary they have to troll. "Why mention Empire?" "Don't overhype." Etc. Maybe you've been burned by good reviews before. Not here, not now. Instead, just embrace the fact that you going to very soon see and be a part of a landmark in cinema. Yes, it is that good.

Hooded Justice
by I am the Terminator
Jul 15th, 2008
01:14:42 PM
Is your brain broken, too?
FUCK NEW YORK!!!
by DarfurFTW
Jul 15th, 2008
01:17:27 PM
WTF is the deal with only new york critics panning it? i am from new york and its fucking bullshit. I am seeing it tonight so i can argue it with facts after it.
And the Heat comparisons...
by Executor
Jul 15th, 2008
01:19:40 PM
Can be seen in the opening bank heist (William Fichtner included!) and the scope and breadth of the story. If you hated Heat because you thought that it had bad writing, or focused on inconsequential characters, that is NOT the case here.

I think Nolan was INSPIRED by Heat to make his own sprawling story of criminals and heroes in Gotham...and the result is not a ripoff or even a QT "homage" (except maybe the first scene), but a wholly original creation that is an unresounding success.

Ow come on now!.
by Gilkuliehe
Jul 15th, 2008
01:22:55 PM
I may have some minor complaints about HEAT but I thing it's a great movie. The way it unfolds, how all "small" characters get to play their role in the story, and how the main ones are constantly reflecting on one another, these are points I think it shares with THE DARK KNIGHT.

And like I said, it has a lot of things tonally that reminded me of the good Michael Mann, specially that "quietness" in the middle of chaos... How suddenly Nolan stops and lets you take a breath with a beautiful shot and a quiet almost imperceptible piece of score.

I loved this movie, I think it is a truly remarkable movie, so rich and dark it gave me nightmares. And to me it's very valid to bring up HEAT. So there.

TDK will undo the Holocaust and 9-11
by g-ride9000
Jul 15th, 2008
01:23:07 PM
*I thinK.
by Gilkuliehe
Jul 15th, 2008
01:25:41 PM
Sorry. And Executor, I also think it's a wholly original creation. Of course. Shit yeah.
Heath Ledger nuked the fridge with the Joker
by Second Try
Jul 15th, 2008
01:27:36 PM
but that fridge was not a lead-lined one.
Thanks for that, Strosmer..
by Hooded Justice
Jul 15th, 2008
01:28:25 PM
That's reassuring. Because I really felt that Batman Begins was going in the direction of Heat: blandness and bright, shiny photography.

Terminator: I've got some pretty concrete reasons as to why HEAT sucked:

Huge amount of screen time given to minor, uninteresting, badly-written characters.

De Niro and Pacino on autopilot. De Niro's mind apparently on something else the whole time; Pacino resorting to SHOUTING every third WORD so the BLAND script would SOUND slightly more INTERESTING.

The godawful scene where De Niro and Pacino show up without a script and try (badly) to improvise (see post above).

The incredibly tedious shoot-out that seems to go on for an hour (the shoot-out: another movie cliché that ran out of steam many years ago).

The three hour running time for a movie that had about one hour's worth of material. Yes: three hours!

So, Terminator, why do YOU think it's a good movie. Please be specific.

Executor
by Jaws Wayne
Jul 15th, 2008
01:28:41 PM
Buddy, if you think questioning a reviewer about his comparisons with no doubt totally different "landmark" movie classics is "trolling" I do not agree with that. This movie sounds like it's definitely worth checking out, if it will give me only half the hard-on it gave Masa I'll be a very happy camper. Totally disliked "Begins" by the way, what an un-thrilling snoozefest that was, Hooded Justice's opinion about that mirrors mine exacltly , but I'm sure this will kick that movie's arse which is not gonna be difficult at all so I think I'm good so Brrring it on...
The hyperbole in this review is remarkable
by Mattyboy122
Jul 15th, 2008
01:29:26 PM
And also a bit nonsensical. I mean, is The Godfather Part II really that big of a leap from the first film? I'd rank them together, to be honest (Apocalypse Now, however, owns both of them). And, of course, the tired claim that Empire is better than Star Wars (revisionism that has flourished in the Lucas-bashing prequel era).

At any rate, I'm looking forward to this flick, even if I don't particularly agree with Nolan's take on the character. Hopefully it lives up to the hype.

Goddamnit.
by Gilkuliehe
Jul 15th, 2008
01:36:28 PM
I came here to discuss this movie, not to lose faith in humanity.

From this point on, I'm only talking to people that think HEAT is a solid crime flick. You know, the sane people.

Anyway, just wanted to say TDK made me think of good old Mann, and gave my reasons why.

What a shocker; deluded Batman fans building castles in the sky
by Kai_Mah'gra
Jul 15th, 2008
01:44:19 PM
....I'm stunned. I really am. Really.

$200M opening weekend gross? Beating Titanic's all-time gross? $163M opening weekend gross? What the hell in Gotham's cesspool are you substance-abusers smoking? Coz, I seriously need to get me some. For the record the top 3 or 4 movies (the Spiderman and POTC, movies and sequels, Star Wars prequelss) with the highest opening weekend grosses pretty much all opened on Holiday weekends at the beginning of Summer or on the 4th of July holiday weekend. There's a very good reason why Studios position movies this way, furthermore, all of the aforementioned movies we're directly geared marketed and rated for that key demographic of Box Office minting audience - kids which as we all know = repeat viewings and parental accompaniment. So naturally, it goes without saying, that it's obviously the height of delusion and general insanity to imagine that a movie that's not going to enjoy the above mentioned advantages, is going to gross anywhere near $200M this weekend; or any other weekend for that matter. Hell, they'll be lucky to get anywhere near the $80 million that Iron Man did. But that's okay, because I'm likely talking to the same crowd that probably imagined that Serenity was the next Titanic and that Superman Returns would do "Spidey-like" numbers at the Box Office (Massawyrm's actual words, I believe; we all know how that one worked out - there's still trying to track down Bryan Singer's career.) So this post is probably an exercise in wasted logic anyway. TDK is probably going to be a good movie and likely an upgrade over the first (which, really isn't saying much, considering the ludicrosity of Batman Begins) and will likewise do decent numbers at the B.O. this weekend; I think they'll be lucky (and happy as a Studio - this is DC property after all) to make anything in the immediate neighbourhood of $60-70 Million. But barely. Outside of geekdom and your average Batman (batshit insane?) fan, no one really gives a crap about this movie. On the flip side, we'll gladly welcome you guys back to the world of the sane and the rational on Monday morning when you thud right back down to earth. But hey, it will do well on DVD sales, right? Right.

Hooded Justice...
by ZoeFan
Jul 15th, 2008
01:57:34 PM
So you hate car chases. The bank heist/gun battle in Heat was tedious. DeNiro and Pacino's improv in the diner scene was bad. So what would you consider good? I'm not looking to critisize, just asking.
PLANT!!!!!!!!
by TheBaxter
Jul 15th, 2008
02:03:11 PM
wtf
He is wrong, DK is really lesser than BB
by theplant
Jul 15th, 2008
02:10:22 PM
First, anything relating to Two Face sucks big bollocks. Second, Rachel was played by a better, prettier actress last time Third : BRUCE WAYNE IS GONE. Fourth : NO ALFRED Five : no conclusion to this movie Six : lots of good ideas half assed. This is the emperor new clothes.
So let me get this straight; Is this film good or not?
by Ray Gamma
Jul 15th, 2008
02:10:44 PM
Because, you know, these reviews are being a bit vague about it...
Holy shit, people bashing HEAT?!
by m_reporter
Jul 15th, 2008
02:11:22 PM
What the bloody fuck is the world coming to? Only someone who knows shit about movies will say that Heat is a bad film.

That's one of rare films that gets all things right, writing, acting, cinematography, production design etc. Also, whoever calls the shootout in Heat boring is only seeking out for attention and is provoking for a response from the rabid fanboyoz. That damn shootout defined how realistic gunfights should be handled on film, its pure adrenaline.

Oh, this is the DK talkback with all the assholes--
by The Octagoner
Jul 15th, 2008
02:15:34 PM
Hi Kai_Mah'gra! "Nobody cares about this movie"-- you're a funny little virgin.

See you Monday you illiterate shitbox!

The New Yorker's Review?
by FatherMcGruderKicksAssForTheLord
Jul 15th, 2008
02:17:20 PM
Who gives a tin shit about about a review of a comic book movie that features an unfunny comic about fucking WINE PORTERS shoehorned into it? Oh, and the comics rotate if you refresh, so maybe your reading included the zinger with the rabbit who says "You think I'm a raw-foodist by choice?" Fuck the New Yorker, fuck their douchee-baguette subscribers, and fuck anyone who says otherwise.

Oh, and Star magazine - that's the finger that's truly on the pulse of what's good in cinema. I mean, did you see how they nailed everyone's love of ABBA in their review of Mamma Mia?

As for the other dissenting reviews on RT ... wait ... who the fuck were they again?

Everyone wants to be the one who calls it different. Joke 'em if they can't take a fuck.

Heat is a great movie.
by Mr. Profit
Jul 15th, 2008
02:18:41 PM
And when I saw the 6 minute sequence attached to I Am Legend I noticed the similarities to Heat right away. I don't get how people can bash a movie like Heat. It's weird how people bash shit on here trying to be edgy and then overpraise some shit because the director shook their hand at Comic Con.
Zoefan...
by Hooded Justice
Jul 15th, 2008
02:19:53 PM
Bank heists? The one in Dog Day Afternoon is excellent, as is the one in Reservoir Dogs. Not to mention the heist in Inside Man. Just off the top of my head, those are decent bank heists.

Good gun battles? Can't think of any. Maybe the bit in The Matrix where they break Lurence Fishbourne out of the skyscraper; the way Tom Cruise handles his gun in Collateral with frightening efficiency, but that isn't a gun battle. (I don't care for Tom Cruise btw!). Guns are a bit of a cop-out actually. I think it's better when they're used in some unusual or unexpected way - like in Saving Private Ryan where Tom Sizemore tries to shoot a German in the thick of battle but his gun doesn't work, so he throws it at the guy instead - or in the same film where they knock down a wall and find themselves in a sudden stand-off with some German troops and get saved by another group of soldiers we didn't even know were there. These are just examples off the top of my head - but they're way better than a bunch of guys just going BAM! BAM! at each other like we used to do as kids playing cowboys and indians.

Kai_Mah'gra
by FatherMcGruderKicksAssForTheLord
Jul 15th, 2008
02:23:01 PM
Has lifetime subscriptions to both The New Yorker AND Star.
I agree mreporter.
by HoboCode
Jul 15th, 2008
02:24:46 PM
Basing heat? Thtaere's just no excuse. Unless your 12 and it didn't ahve enough men in tights for your tastes.
must...not...read...
by Project424
Jul 15th, 2008
02:29:46 PM
I avoided all Hellboy circlejerks and was pleasantly surprised... perhaps avoiding you fuckers is the new "in thing".
More HEAT bashing
by Hooded Justice
Jul 15th, 2008
02:32:19 PM
I don't care about provoking or whatever: I genuinely don't understand why some people like HEAT - and I've spelt out very specific and fatal flaws to that movie in my above posts. I remember watching that movie in utter disbelief - I couldn't believe that any director could make such bland, lifeless scenes and waste the talent of people such as de Niro and Pacino. I mean, that scene they share in the cafe where they try to make up their lines - that scene is LEGENDARY amongst movie fans for its awfulness and lack of professionalism.

As I've pointed out before, there are many specific and demonstrable reasons why HEAT fails as a movie. Those talkbackers who seem to see it as the second coming are so far unable to explain what's so good about it.

benditlikelucas
by FatherMcGruderKicksAssForTheLord
Jul 15th, 2008
02:38:21 PM
No way, good sir, The New Yorker's still totally relevant (IF your view and understanding of the world-at-large begins at 59th street and ends at 110th).
Two things: great article, thanks for it..
by Aeghast
Jul 15th, 2008
02:42:37 PM
..and, get a new keyboard, Massawyrm!
I hate sounding like I'm defending Titanic..
by hank henshaw
Jul 15th, 2008
02:43:21 PM
but that movie (which I don't like) had something for everyone: romance, visual effects, comedy, action, was a period movie, etc. T & A is only a big deal in the U.S. and it was so harmless that even there had a PG-13 rating. I can put this other way, if the Star Wars prequels (other movies I'm not partial to) couldn't make Titanic-like numbers, much less a very dark Batman movie.
I agree with what someone said before:
by Aeghast
Jul 15th, 2008
02:43:29 PM
" Now I want to see it even more than before... never thought it would be possible."
LOL Geekgasm
by Aeghast
Jul 15th, 2008
02:44:22 PM
I remember that one! Freakin' great (well, old Simpsons stuff—whaddya gonna do..?)
Hooded InJustice
by I am the Terminator
Jul 15th, 2008
02:45:36 PM
You look like you're trying to get PWNED. Here are some concrete reasons why Heat PWNS you:

The screen time given to minor but totally interesting, well-written characters adds to the overall epic quality and helps in understanding the world in which the characters inhabit and the people they effect. PWNED.

De Niro and Pacino on PWNINGpilot. De Niro's mind is apparently razor focused; Pacino resorts to shouting because his character was written as a stressed out coke head. That was part of Pacino's preparation for the character and you would know this if you took the time to listen to any of the DVD extras. PWNED.

The famous table scene was not wholly improvised as you can clearly see script pages in any number of set photos. Not to mention the fact that Pacino references "eight-ball hemorages" (a detail written and used in several other Mann films) or that the completed scene was pieced together by numerous takes of the same dialog but was mostly comprised of one particular take. If you think they made up that entire scene only when the cameras were running, you may be more of an idiot than you appear. PWNED.

One of the most memorable shoot-outs in the history of cinema. If you find shoot-outs tiresome, then you must not like action or see a lot of movies. You sound like a really boring person. PWNED.

A three hour running time is about perfect for a modern epic crime drama. PWNED.

Oh, right...
by hank henshaw
Jul 15th, 2008
02:46:14 PM
I don't think box office intake has anything to do with movie quality. TDK maybe IS the best creation in the history of mankind, I don't know and I don't care, but it will not make more money than Titanic... which isn't really the highest grossing movie ever when you take in consideration dollar inflation.
Hooded Justice
by FatherMcGruderKicksAssForTheLord
Jul 15th, 2008
02:46:33 PM
"I don't care about whatever: I genuinely understand why some people like HEAT - I remember watching that movie in utter disbelief - I couldn't believe that any director could make such scenes, and the talent of people such as de Niro and Pacino. I mean, that scene they share in the cafe where they make up their lines - that scene is LEGENDARY amongst movie fans."

There seemed to be some typos in your post, so I fixed 'em for you. No thanks necessary.

More Heat PWNING
by I am the Terminator
Jul 15th, 2008
02:52:21 PM
I don't care about provoking or whatever: I genuinely don't understand why some people don't get HEAT - and I've spelled out very specific reasons as to why you should think it's awesome in my above posts. I remember watching that movie in utter joy - I couldn't believe that any director could make such an awesome, crime epic with the talents of people such as De Niro and Pacino. I mean, that scene they share in the cafe where they don't talk so much as read each other's minds and intentions - is LEGENDARY amongst movie fans for its intensity and foreshadowing.

As I've pointed out before, there are many specific and demonstrable reasons why Heat PWNS as a movie. Those talkbackers who seem to see it as bland and lifeless are, so far, unable to explain what's so bad about it.

NEW AND IMPROVED!

PWNED!!

Soccer Mom: "I heard that movie is awful!
by CreasyBear
Jul 15th, 2008
02:54:22 PM
Very dark and disturbing. There is no way I'm taking my boys to see that. They're in fifth grade, but from what Patty told me, her boys had nightmares, and I'm not paying my hard-earned money for Cody and Chase to have nightmares! You can't even take your kids to see a Batman movie now, for Pete's sake!"
Pacino/Deniro scene.
by HoboCode
Jul 15th, 2008
02:56:59 PM
I don't know where you hang Hooded but in my world that scene between Pacino and Deniro is universally revered. It's utterly fantastic in my opinion. I'm not sure what was "unprofessional" about it, but it was a stellar scene just for it's sheer gravitas. The bank heist is not only one of the most perfectly executed action sequences of its kind, but manages to culminate all of the proceeding drama to perfection. Pacino, who admittedly hams it up to the nth degree, turns in one of his most memorable and likable performances. The little subplots of the film involving Van Zant, Breedan, Waingro, Eady, Lauren, etc. add richness and intricacy to the plot and make us care about, yes, even secondary characters. The cinematography of the film is stunning and visceral. The writing is some of the best and coolest you'll ever see/hear in a film. The direction and overall tone of the film is consistent, unwaning, and epic in scope. Eliot Goldenthal's score is understated but effective and haunting. And the film's conclusion with one on one hunt between cop and thief is uncompromising and heartfelt. Is that enough reasons?
CreasyBear
by FatherMcGruderKicksAssForTheLord
Jul 15th, 2008
02:58:00 PM
You forgot:

"But Jerry & I are going to get a babysitter this friday and go see Mamma Mia - Star magazine said it was joyous. I miss ABBA!"

so, ... you liked it?
by 300 monkeys
Jul 15th, 2008
03:00:41 PM
Hobocode
by FatherMcGruderKicksAssForTheLord
Jul 15th, 2008
03:00:58 PM
All good points. I think HJ is just trying to be a stink-stick.
The Guy Who Slept Through Everything
by 300 monkeys
Jul 15th, 2008
03:04:04 PM
"Aside from losing my virginity and finding $100 bucks" - THAT's an awfully big coincidence - are you sure it wasn't a tip?
Hooded Justice
by fassbinder79
Jul 15th, 2008
03:05:07 PM
I'm sorry but anyone who says that "Heat" was a bad movie is an IDIOT. Dark Knight is going to own all our asses. Just shut the fuck up and buy your goddamn ticket.
I'm awfully proud of that joke
by 300 monkeys
Jul 15th, 2008
03:05:08 PM
Heat is a classic
by DoctorWho?
Jul 15th, 2008
03:05:48 PM
Acting. Pacing. Characters. Design. Score...the score is haunting and beatiful. Mann shoots L.A. like no one else! And that gun fight is loud and frightening. The sound of those guns reverberating in that corridor is something else. I think maybe you have to really like Mann's style to dig this film.
Why Heat is Great...
by ZoeFan
Jul 15th, 2008
03:05:49 PM
It turns characters into people (people have flaws even the good guys, bad guys have real lives outside of their "jobs", bad guys also have good sides to them). Real life action sequences. The gun battle in the Matrix was mentioned as a Great action sequence. And I concur, it is a GREAT action sequence. But it's not real. The gun battle in Heat is as real as a gun battle can get in a movie. Yet it keeps minor movie-esqe elements in it to maintain the viewer's interest. Despite what some say, the performances across the board by the actors is superb in Heat. Those are just some starters.
Kai_Mah'gra
by WickedJester
Jul 15th, 2008
03:07:30 PM
They usually do open on holidays so they can get the extra days in their total, etc. However, since this is probably the first movie I've ever seen have showings ALL NIGHT LONG, I highly doubt they'll have an issue because it didn't open on a Wednesday.

To suggest this movie will not make as much as Iron Man's opening is laughable, at best. I mean, I'm sure you felt quite cool hitting that 'Post Talkback' button and shredding some fanboys with knowledge, but at the end of the day you come off as someone that didn't get the Batman underoos he wanted when he was younger.

Why you ask? Well....

The highest opening was Spiderman 3 with 151m+, and it opened May 4th. Not a holiday weekend, not even in the 'summer blockbuster months'.

Spiderman 1. 113m. May 3rd (also not a holiday weekend) .

Shrek the 3rd? 122mMay 18th.

POTC opened after July 4th (July 7th to be exact). So you can throw that out the window. Next time you try to bring everyone down with negativity, atleast make sure it checks out.

http://tinyurl.com/5c2 zsh
At the bottom, Top 25 Openings.

This talkback deserves a new class of troll... who's gonna give it to us?
And That's POTC: DMC (135m). Sorry for the confusion.
by WickedJester
Jul 15th, 2008
03:10:37 PM
Watchmen
by andtheflesh
Jul 15th, 2008
03:12:57 PM

Why hasn't AICN said anything about the Watchmen Trailer attached to the Dark Knight? The entire time I was thinking we'd get a 30 second teaser type thing. Nopes, not according to Chud. Get ready for 2 full minutes of actual footage. Get ready to see Dr. Manhattan!

http://tinyurl.com/54pes6

the rumbler chase WAS really stupid ...
by 300 monkeys
Jul 15th, 2008
03:17:24 PM
totally outside the tone of the rest of the film - Way to destroy the city you love so much, Caped Crusader! I hope that the villains are responsible for all of the collateral damage in TDK ...
C'mon 300...
by DoctorWho?
Jul 15th, 2008
03:23:20 PM
If you wanna make an omelet...you've gotta break a few eggs.
Batman's defense to destroying roofs in Begins..
by Bouncy X
Jul 15th, 2008
03:24:58 PM
"i'm The Batman bitch!!"
Anyone else not buying all this praise?
by sott68
Jul 15th, 2008
03:26:14 PM
I am skeptical. I want it to be good but when everyone and their mother hype's it so much, it never lives up to expectations.
Philip Seymour Hoffman as THE PENGUIN,
by Uncle Stan
Jul 15th, 2008
03:28:33 PM
The evil genius comic book Penguin, not some fucked up sewer mutant who bears no resemblance to the character.
The Dark Exaggerator
by Darth Rosenberg
Jul 15th, 2008
03:29:23 PM
Clearly this is the greatest movie, nay the greatest thing ever made...
Just putting questions out there for discussion
by strosmer
Jul 15th, 2008
03:40:46 PM
Sheez. That's AICN for ya. I haven't made any claims, just curious as to what people think the opening weekend numbers will be. I don't see any reason why TDK can't break the opening weekend record. Sounds like a sure thing with all the talk of advance sell-outs and round-the-clock screenings. Can it beat Titanic? Probably not, but I'll have fun speculating the possibility all the same. It's not like I'll be crying for mommy if this movie doesn't break any records. I'm excited to see it is all. If you're not, there's just no talking to you.
Having now read all the comments on this thread...
by fassbinder79
Jul 15th, 2008
03:41:08 PM
it is clear to me how so many people might not be jazzed or pulled in by the hype surrounding this film. Although any so called film fan who says Heat was bad or LA Confidential for that matter doesn't know what the hell they are talking about. Those are two of the best films that came out of the 90's. But I do think that Aint It Cool is partially to blame for why people are nervous about getting too pumped for this film. I didn't like Memento. I wasn't that into Insomnia either. But BB was fantastic and The Prestige was a work of genius. It looks like Nolan is on a roll with Dark Knight. The trailers are incredible. I don't see how anyone could look at the clips of Ledger or the composition of shots and think that the film looks bad. But here's the problem...AICN has really pushed some mediocre films this summer. Indy 4 was terrible. Iron Man was subpar. Hancock sucked the big one and Kung Fu Panda wasn't very good either. Wall E was probably the only movie I agreed with AICN about this summer. I haven't seen Hellboy 2 yet (i liked the first one okay) but it didn't look very good from the trailers so I'm going to wait and see it when it comes out on blu-ray. Dark Knight is probably going to be as AMAZING as Massawyrm said it is but I think this unfortunately going to be a case of never cry wolf. So, many films this summer blew so now when a truly GREAT one comes along no one believes it because of the all the praise for so many bad ones before it. This is why in all your geek film fanaticism you guys need to be very careful what films you start calling "angelina jolie's pussy juice" or whatever. Bottom line - Dark Knight will rule the summer and in my opinion will most likely wind up being one of the best escapist entetainments EVER made. I trust Nolan. The guy is a beast. It is time to bow down to the god of summer. Haters make your exit. Your loss...Our gain.
kai mahgra is having us on
by slappy jones
Jul 15th, 2008
03:42:20 PM
he has to be. the film will have a fucking enormous opening weekend.
PWND!
by Hooded Justice
Jul 15th, 2008
03:43:03 PM
Thanks to everyone who rose to the challenge of explaining why HEAT is good (I discount those who simply copied-and-pasted my posts. Er.....why? Doesn't exactly prove anything - except that my argument is more convincing than yours! PWND!)

Okay, you're going to laugh, but I would pay good money to find out what 'PWND!' actually means. I've seen it used a lot but I'm stumped. Here are my guesses:

1. It actually means 'OWNED' as in 'I own our ass' but for some reason people have started using a P instead of the O.

2. It is actually short for 'Pawned' which I suppose means 'I just brought your ass into a pawn shop and exchanged it for cash.' Close? I'm dying to know.

In any case no-one has been able to defend HEAT at all , though I bow to Zoefan who made an honest stab at it. Come on guys! Give me SOMETHING! How to you explain away:

Pacino and De Niro's phoned-in performances. I mean, its DE NIRO and PACINO!!! Two of the finest American screen actors of all time! But both of them were clearly into their post-retirement, take-the-paycheck-and-run periods. This explains de Niro's sleepwaking through the movie. And by the way, Pacino did not evolve his patented SHOUT-every-third-WORD-of-my-P ERFORMANCE-over-the-PHONE acting method for 'Heat' alone - he's been using it in EVERY movie since Scent Of a Woman, with no exceptions. Don't make me laugh with some cock-a-mamie story about him preparing for this particular role. Which leads me nicely onto....

The notorious cafe scene. Ah yes, the moment when the two legendary giants of cinema finally share a scene. Will sparks fly? Will it be a masterclass in suble acting? Will it be a tense and riveting battle of wits?

No, they'll grunt and shrug and try to make up some lines and then give up.

DO NOT try to tell me there was a script for this. There's just no way. Far more likely is that De Niro and Pacino are so arrogant that they insisted they could improvise on the spot - and Michael Mann was too afraid to say no. THAT'S why this scene is so abysmal. Don't tell me there was a script: that's insulting to all involved.

Please explain why the following is good:

Good guys: BAM! BAM!

Bad guys: BAM! BAM! BAM!

Good guys: BAM! BAM! BAM! YOU'RE DEAD!

Bad guys: NO WE'RE NOT! YOU'RE DEAD! BAM! BAM! BAM! BAM!

If some one can explain why this isn't something we can all quite easily do at home, I'd be grateful.

but it won't make 200 million ow
by slappy jones
Jul 15th, 2008
03:45:37 PM
nor will it beat titanic but it is going to fucking huge
Jeez, Massawyrm. Raise my expectations much?
by DarthCorleone
Jul 15th, 2008
03:47:28 PM
Hope it lives up to it...
Batman & Robin
by Axl Z
Jul 15th, 2008
03:47:51 PM
Was also Oscar worthy for Schwarzenegger
TDK will pick up your kids from school
by Falling_Gruber
Jul 15th, 2008
03:47:52 PM
best joker would have been.....
by slappy jones
Jul 15th, 2008
03:49:08 PM
...romeros IF he had been a brutal murderer. Imagine that same exact performance but with murders. He would have been terrifying and he looks so good as the joker....Imagine that performance while he is laughing it up stomping on someones head or running over people in a car...he would have been great.
Kai_Mah'gra
by fassbinder79
Jul 15th, 2008
03:50:22 PM
Titanic didn't make 200 mil the opening weekend. More like 20-30 million.
PS-Titanic
by fassbinder79
Jul 15th, 2008
03:54:12 PM
Titanic was a film that built up box office momentum over time because so many little girls went to see it over and over again. Dark Knight has the ability to top Titanic because the opening weekends nowadays are much greater, word of mouth and the simple fact that guys like me have already bought tickets to see it twice and expect to see it many more times over the coming weeks. I'll probably see it at least twice in the Imax and three times in a regular theater during matinee showings. If men come out for this movie like women did for Titanic in the 90's this film is going to be a MEGA BLOCKBUSTER that will make Spielberg jealous as fuck.
Forget TDK beating Titanic.. unless
by daveyf
Jul 15th, 2008
03:56:29 PM
You all go see it 10 times in theater. Them little sissy girls were like all over Leo back then. I saw grown homos (with their wives) crying during the movie. The same homos who give TDK shit for being too dark and no fun.
After reading the jizz fest over Hellboy II here...
by DoctorWho?
Jul 15th, 2008
04:03:08 PM
...I am kind of skeptical. I mean damn...Mori made Hellboy II sound like an in depth character study rather than the light-hearted, CG joke fest it turned out to be.
Mass is dead-on
by hallowhitch31
Jul 15th, 2008
04:08:46 PM
This is the best Batman movie ever. 'Begins' even pales stacked up against this bad-boy.
daveyf
by Gilkuliehe
Jul 15th, 2008
04:20:11 PM
I cried in Titanic. And here in 2008 I think TDK is amazing, beautiful and yes, very dark. I am also not a "homo". You are not cool, sir.
Gilkuliehe
by daveyf
Jul 15th, 2008
04:25:42 PM
I wasn't trying to be cool. You are or you're not.
The Dark Knight Cured My Cancer AND My AIDS!
by Alex De Large
Jul 15th, 2008
04:34:46 PM
Harry write this?
by br1947
Jul 15th, 2008
04:40:11 PM
Damnit Masswyrm, I'm trying to lower my expectations before seeing it so it will not disappoint!!! This is not helping!!! But i hope you're right.
I already had insanely high expectations
by Shepard Wong
Jul 15th, 2008
04:47:08 PM
I think the reviews I've seen today may have raised them to a truly unreasonable level. I keep seeing comparisons to Empire, one of the great movie going experiences I ever had as a kid. If this is even close to as good as everyone says it is, I may see it 10 times in the theater. And lightly off topic, now I have to watch Heat again. I remmeber seeing it in the theater the day it was released and being really disappointed. I'll have to watch it again.
"PWNED"
by Ray Gamma
Jul 15th, 2008
04:59:51 PM
It's an internet meme, by which definition I mean it is meaningless to anyone who is not a flabby white manchild with bitch tits who still lives with his parents even though he is 33 years old.
Holy smoke
by kungfuhustler84
Jul 15th, 2008
05:05:07 PM
I really need to stop reading these reviews, or my expectations will be so astronomically high that the actual film could never hold up.
Forget Nicholson?
by Iowa Snot Client
Jul 15th, 2008
05:05:33 PM
I'm still trying to.
it's good to be an australian
by chipps
Jul 15th, 2008
05:06:40 PM
I'm not going to read any of these post because of people like that harvey dent is dead character. fuck you. i am just assuming some cunt is posting spoilers. but on account of the fact that i am an australian i'm off to watch the dark knight, well, now! I won't spoil it when i come back though. Fucking idoit
Harry Would Have Also Giggled Like a School Girl
by kevinwillis.net
Jul 15th, 2008
05:21:48 PM
Early and often.
JAWS WAYNE
by Executor
Jul 15th, 2008
05:21:50 PM
If you thought Batman Begins was a snoozefest then why even bother with this one? Sit it out and we'll all be happier for it.